Friday, 8 April 2016

Clime Investment Management Ltd (CIW, CAM, CAMPA)

Trawling back through previous posts is always interesting. One stock I discussed back in May 2013 was the Clime Capital preference share (CAMPA). These shares mature next year so it's worth a quick update. 

CAMPA are issued by the listed investment company, Clime Capital (CAM). CAM are managed by Clime Investment Management (CIW). 

CAMPA were issued in 2007 at a price of $2.40. At the time of the review in 2013 the price was $2.14, and given the maturity conversion formula, I couldn't understand for the life of me why the price was still so high. CAMPA are now $1.1950. At maturity in May 2017, CAMPA shares will convert to CAM shares at a ratio of 1.36206* for each 1 CAMPA share held. CAM shares currently trade at $.77, so the notional conversion value is $1.05. CAM shares aren't popular at the moment - they trade less than NTA. If you apply the conversion calculation to the NTA value (i.e. assume CIW will trade closer to NTA), then we have a conversion value of $1.18, which is pretty close to the current CAMPA price. 

CAMPA pay out a big fat dividend - 18c p.a., fully franked. Given the timing, it looks like there will be another 18c or 25.71c including franking credits of dividends to be paid before maturity. That equates to a yield of 21.6% including franking credits. 

The elephant in the room is the CAM share price - its performance has been sub par, thanks to an average performance of the underlying portfolio. If this trend continues, then the CAMPA value also diminishes. If the share price stays at $1.05 (e.g. the NTA stays flat and the discount to NTA persists), the net return drops to 11.7c or 9.8%. If the CAM share price trends down further then potentially all of the income is wiped out. 

Looks like money could be made from here - but not hugely interesting for me. 

Kristian 

No position in CAM, CAMP, own CIW

*not updated for any further share issues since 2013

Sunday, 7 February 2016

Pay More Fees(?)

I find TED Talks a good way to pass the time, especially when sitting in traffic. I recently stumbled across a TED interview with Jim Simons - founder of Renaissance Technologies. Apart from being brilliant and incredibly successful, he also charges one of the highest (if not highest?) fees in the industry. Get this: Renaissance charge 5 & 44 (see around 15.40 in the talk). What the? That means they charge 5% of FUM plus an additional 44% in performance fees. That makes the standard 1-2 & 20 look like chicken feed.

I don't know the exact performance of Renaissance, however every number I've ever heard make you blush. Reportedly, their flagship fund has returned 35% for over 20 years - net of fees. You'd be happy to pay 5/44 for that sort of performance, and their pre-fee performance is off the charts. 

It reminds me of 2014 when a friend and I went and watched the Monaco GP. Right along the front of the harbour are the really big boats (as opposed to the guys worth just a few hundred $m around the sides of the harbour). One afternoon we Googled the owners of the monster boats and it turned out that Sea Owl (a 62m Super Yacht) was owned by Robert Mercer; one of the co-managers of Renaissance. No wonder he can afford that sort of boat with that sort of performance and fees.  

All of this makes the Australian union superannuation marketing around the benefits of lower fees just a little bit incomplete. Sure, a lot of hedge funds don't add value over the long term, but there are anomalies - there are some who charge exorbitant fees and deliver exceptional performance. 

Kristian 

Monday, 25 January 2016

The Big Short


The Big Short was a fantastic read and the movie truly does it full justice (I finally got around to watching it on the weekend). While The Wolf of Wall St was sensational for a laugh, it abysmally failed to acknowledge the damage done to clients and community and therefore probably inspired plenty of wannabe Jordan Belforts (I even know a few). The Big Short however manages to tell a complex and sombre story in a digestible and entertaining manner. You walk out both laughing at the one-liners yet also shaking your head at just how screwed up the financial system was (is?). 

Please go and see it if you haven't already done so. 

Kristian 

Friday, 15 January 2016

ThinkSmart (TSM)

Happy new year to everyone. 

TSM was a good investment last year, albeit I sold it a little while ago and therefore jumped off way too early. With the recent run-up in the share price, it reminded me of the Feedback Loop post I wrote last year where I analysed my decisions and identified key areas for improvement. TSM fits the 'getting bored with a situation' category to some extent however that is being a bit harsh given decent money was also made. 

A massive buy-back was undertaken toward the end of 2014 where shareholders could tender their shares in a price range of 31c to 42c. It reminded me at the time of Charlie Munger's tip to look for cannibal companies (companies that are buying back huge amounts of their stock). The founder had floated the stock back in June 2007 (just before the GFC hit) for $2.15 and was now offering to buy back a lot of stock for an absolute fraction of the price. There was some criticism about the move (and the threat to de-list the business), but I just figured the stock was incredibly cheap (PE of less than 4 from memory) and if a really smart guy is offering to buy other people's stock and not offering his own holding then the situation must be interesting. 

And boy has the business gone on a nice little tear since. Looking back over the announcements, it was only a matter of months before an upgrade was announced, an extension of the contract with Dixons Carphone and now another upgrade. Sure, some of the upgrades are FX related, but their business (now based entirely in the UK) has shot the lights out in GBP. I wouldn't be surprised to see another upgrade come and with the stock still cheap I wouldn't be surprised to see the share price march upward more. It just goes to show how buy-backs can be a great leading indicator, ignoring what the smart money is doing can be dangerous and yes - patience is a virtue.

Kristian 

Disclosure: no position in the above name.

Tuesday, 8 December 2015

PMP Ltd (PMP)

Charlie Sheen on answering a question as to why he used prostitutes - "I don't pay them for sex, I pay them to leave". And just like Charlie had a clearly defined exit strategy with women, we need a good exit strategy with stocks. 

PMP has been a wonderful investment over the last number of years, despite a business that is in long term decline. However, the business is in decline and unless something major happens like industry consolidation, it's hard to see the glory days returning. So this will probably remain a business that will not grow in value and therefore has a ceiling on its valuation. I modelled a basic scenario of declining revenues of 8% p.a. (it's average decline since 2012), maintaining EBITDA margins (which is probably generous - you can't cut costs forever!) and assuming the business has a terminal value in 5 years time of 4* PBT, and discounting back at 10% I get a valuation of 75c. This number of course is based on some pretty simplistic assumptions and could of course be wrong. 

But at 50c, and assuming my numbers are roughly right, the discount rate being factored in by the market is over 20%. Given PMP re-financed a bond at 6.43% p.a. plus generous terms in its favour, it looks like the equity market is treating PMP pretty harsh.  While this may be all true, what is also true is the market may never want to pay up for a declining business: it could easily be 'cheap' forever, and a stock trading at a discount to valuation alone without a catalyst is rarely a good enough reason to buy at least in my experience  - unless it is a huge discount. 

The other issue I consider far more these days is return on my time. I would prefer to spend my time on ideas that will yield a much bigger ROI such as companies that can grow and get re-rated by the market and value opportunities that represent massive value.  

Hence the reason for recently selling PMP. 

Kristian 

Disclosure: no position in the above name

Thursday, 26 November 2015

Devine Ltd (DVN)

Follow up post to comments on the previous DVN post...

As noted by other people and my follow up comments, the situation with CIMIC smells. And the smell gets worse. A separate, non-binding offer has been made for DVN for 90c, which of course trumps CIMIC's 75c offer. As the takeover would be via Scheme of Arrangement and therefore requires 75% of votes, CIMIC can matter-of-factly block the deal as it owns 50.63%.

So this has truly forced CIMIC to show its hand. CIMIC has responded by saying they are proceeding with their offer, effectively confirming they want to buy DVN for a song. Typically with takeover trades you can justify buying a bit above the bid price in the hope another bidder comes along. That probably won't work in this case given CIMIC's stance. I suspect it would take a much higher bid to dislodge CIMIC and your guess is as good as mine as to whether that might happen.

At 80c it is a tough call. CIMIC can block any other deal and the share price could drop plenty when their offer expires. I've been selling recently, and I'm out completely.

Kristian

Disclosure: no position in the above.  

Tuesday, 10 November 2015

Devine Ltd (DVN)

Some good news (albeit a bit lucky) from DVN: major shareholder CIMIC has announced an intended takeover for the remaining shares it doesn't own. The offer price is 75c cash and will have minimal conditions. Successful or not, CIMIC is rolling the board and will appointing a new CEO to turn the business around, and as it already owns 50.6%, CIMIC effectively controls the company and can call the shots. 

Good to see a major shareholder taking an active position.  

This leaves the question of what to do with DVN shares. As CIMIC owns such a large stake, it's not likely another bidder will bother coming along. This means CIMIC will end up with all the company (if it gets to 90% it may just move to compulsory acquisition) or end up with somewhere between 50.6% and 90%. 

Given the offer is 50% of book value, you could argue that CIMIC is being opportunistic, but I wouldn't be doing anything different if in their shoes. If you decline the offer and hold your shares, you are taking the view new management will come in and clean the place up, and there is always a possibility CIMIC will come back later with a higher offer to mop up residual shareholdings. That's not an unreasonable bet. 

Kristian